Mortgage Disputes Australia — Your Rights and How to Resolve Them

When something goes wrong with a home loan — whether it’s a lender acting unreasonably, incorrect fees, a disputed credit assessment, or hardship assistance refused without justification — Australians have real rights and effective pathways to resolve the dispute.

The Australian mortgage market is regulated by multiple overlapping frameworks: the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (NCCP), ASIC oversight, the Banking Code of Practice, and the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). Together, these give borrowers meaningful protections.

Your Legal Protections as a Borrower

National Consumer Credit Protection Act (NCCP)

The NCCP is the primary federal law governing consumer lending in Australia. Key protections include:

Responsible lending obligations: Lenders must make reasonable enquiries about your financial situation, verify that information, and assess whether the loan is not unsuitable for you. A loan is unsuitable if you couldn’t repay it without substantial hardship, or if it doesn’t meet your requirements and objectives.

If a lender failed to make proper enquiries and you ended up with a loan that was unsuitable, you may have grounds to challenge the lending assessment. ASIC and the courts have taken action against lenders who systematically failed to meet responsible lending obligations.

Right to financial hardship assistance: If you are experiencing financial hardship (unemployment, illness, natural disaster, other reasonable cause), you have a legal right to request your lender vary your contract. The lender must consider your request and respond. Options include:

• Temporarily reducing or suspending repayments
• Extending the loan term to reduce repayments
• Capitalising arrears

Unfair contract terms: The Australian Consumer Law prohibits unfair contract terms in standard form consumer contracts (which almost all mortgages are). An unfair term can be voided by a court.

ASIC Enforcement

ASIC is the national regulator for consumer credit. ASIC can:

• Investigate complaints against licensees
• Issue infringement notices
• Seek civil penalties in court
• Ban individuals from the credit industry

For borrowers, ASIC is not primarily a dispute resolution mechanism — that’s AFCA’s role. But ASIC’s existence as a regulator with enforcement powers creates systemic accountability that shapes lender behaviour.

The Banking Code of Practice

The Banking Code of Practice (the Code) is a voluntary commitment by major banks (ABA members) to service standards exceeding minimum legal requirements. Key borrower-relevant provisions:

• Banks must provide hardship assistance to eligible customers
• Banks must act fairly and reasonably in all dealings
• Banks cannot charge default fees if the default was caused by the bank’s own error
• Banks must ensure that credit is not unsuitable for your needs
• Banks must explain loan terms clearly and proactively

When a bank breaches its Code commitments, you can escalate the complaint to AFCA with reference to the specific Code provision breached.

Mortgage Brokers — Best Interest Duty

Since 1 January 2021, mortgage brokers in Australia are subject to a best interests duty. This means brokers must recommend loans that are in your best interest, not simply loans that generate higher commissions.

If a broker recommended a loan that was not in your best interest — e.g., a product with higher fees and rates when a better-suited product was available — you may have grounds for complaint via AFCA.

The best interests duty is enforced by ASIC. Brokers must document their reasoning for recommendations and prioritise your needs over commission incentives.

Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR)

The first step in any mortgage dispute is your lender’s internal dispute resolution process. Lenders are legally required to have an IDR process and must respond to complaints within strict timeframes:

• Acknowledgement: Within 1 business day (for written complaints)
• Resolution: Within 30 calendar days for most complaints; 45 days for credit-related complaints (extended in some circumstances)

To lodge a complaint with your lender:

1. Identify the correct complaints department (check the bank’s website — usually “Customer Relations” or “Complaints”)
2. Submit in writing (email or written form) — this creates a paper trail
3. Specify: what happened, what the issue is, what outcome you want
4. Note the date and keep records

If the lender resolves the complaint to your satisfaction, no further escalation is needed.

Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA)

AFCA is Australia’s free, external dispute resolution scheme for financial complaints. If you cannot resolve a complaint through IDR within the required timeframe, or if you are not satisfied with the outcome, you can escalate to AFCA.

Key facts about AFCA:

• Free to complainants
• Binding on financial firms — if AFCA makes a determination, the lender must comply
• Compensation limits: Up to $1,000,000 for home loan-related disputes (increased from $500,000 in 2021)
• Accessible: Online at afca.org.au, by phone, or by post
• Scope: Covers banks, credit unions, non-bank lenders, mortgage brokers, and most other credit providers

What AFCA can help with:

• Disputed loan repayments or fees
• Incorrect credit assessments or responsible lending failures
• Hardship applications refused without justification
• Incorrect entries on your credit report related to your mortgage
• Broker misconduct and best interest duty breaches
• Mortgage discharge issues or exit fees

What AFCA cannot help with:

• Commercial disputes (though some small business lending is included)
• Disputes outside the 6-year time limit
• Court proceedings already underway
• Investment decisions (as opposed to lending disputes)

The AFCA Complaints Process

1. Lodge complaint online at afca.org.au — you’ll need to have already attempted IDR first (or waited 30 days without resolution)
2. AFCA notifies the financial firm and gives them an opportunity to resolve the complaint directly
3. If not resolved, AFCA reviews the complaint — may involve information requests from both parties
4. AFCA issues a determination — the firm must accept or appeal in the court system (uncommon)
5. If you accept the determination, it is binding on both parties

Escalation Table: Mortgage Dispute Pathway

The vast majority of borrower-lender disputes are resolved at stage 1 or 2.

Key Articles in This Section

• NCCP Responsible Lending Obligations Explained
• Mortgage Hardship — Your Rights and How to Apply
• How to Complain About Your Bank or Lender
• AFCA — How to Lodge a Mortgage Complaint
• Best Interest Duty for Mortgage Brokers
• Disputing a Credit Assessment — Can You Challenge a Loan Refusal?
• Mortgage Default — What Happens and What Are Your Rights?
• Unfair Bank Fees — Can You Get Them Back?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the time limit for making an AFCA complaint? Generally, 6 years from when you first knew or should have known about the problem, or 2 years from IDR resolution — whichever is later. Some circumstances have shorter limits. Check the AFCA website for complaint-specific time limits.

Can I complain to AFCA about a mortgage broker? Yes. Mortgage brokers are AFCA members and subject to its jurisdiction. If your broker breached the best interests duty, gave you misleading information, or placed you in an unsuitable loan, AFCA can assess that complaint.

Does lodging a complaint affect my credit rating? No. Lodging a dispute with your lender or AFCA does not affect your credit file. If your lender has already reported a default and you dispute it as incorrect, AFCA can order the credit entry corrected.

For advice tailored to your situation, speak with a licensed financial adviser or solicitor. You can find a financial adviser through the ASIC financial advisers register or MoneySmart.

Hardship Notices and Mortgage Deferrals

Under the NCCP, if you are experiencing hardship (illness, unemployment, natural disaster), you can request a hardship variation to your loan contract. The lender must consider the request and respond within a reasonable time.

Hardship options typically include:

• Repayment deferral: Pausing repayments for a defined period (interest typically capitalises)
• Reduced repayments: Temporarily lowering repayments (with the shortfall added to the loan balance)
• Loan term extension: Extending the overall loan period to reduce the required repayment amount
• Interest-only period: Temporarily switching to interest-only repayments

If a lender refuses a hardship request without adequate reason, or takes adverse action (like registering a default) while a hardship request is in progress, this is a matter for AFCA.

Always lodge hardship requests in writing and keep records of all communications. Do not stop making repayments without written lender agreement — unilateral payment stoppage can result in default registration.

← Back to Mortgages